Transgender people should use facilities designated to their biological status says Monmouth MP

By Christopher Gage in Politics

MONMOUTH MP David Davies has come under heavy fire after suggesting that transgender people should be forced to use lavatories which correspond to their birth gender.

David Davies, the member of parliament for Monmouth, said in a newspaper column last week that those who identify as the opposite sex, should not be allowed to use bathroom facilities of their preference.

The storm brewed after Mr Davies’ comments were picked up by a pro-trans group aghast at what it deemed ‘unfeeling’ and ‘incendiary’ remarks fired at people who struggle with their gender identity.

In a column for the South Wales Argus, Mr Davies argued that transgender people should use facilities designated to their biological status, in a move echoing the ‘bathroom bill’ controversy in the United States.

“Some might say I am on the ‘wrong side of history’ and ‘bigoted’, but I would maintain that anyone in possession of male genitalia should be expected to use male facilities regardless of what gender they feel they are,” he said.

“If a man decides to register him/herself as a woman, should he/she have the right to use women’s toilets, changing rooms, hospital wards, etc.? This would clearly have an impact on the rights of women using those facilities.”

The comments came after equalities minister Justine Greening, another Conservative MP, proposed changing the law to allow transgender people to legally change their gender identity without meeting current medical requirements which demand individuals live as their preferred gender for two years before making the official transition.

Davies, mindful of a subject given increasing media attention and political debate, said ‘understanding and compassion’ should be shown towards anyone ‘confused about their gender’ but the ‘rights of others’ must also be considered.

A consultation on reforming the Gender Recognition Act 2004 will be begin in the autumn.

Add Comment
Add Comment


Comments are not moderated

Daniel Pearce · 11 days ago · Report

Not sure what it says about Monmouthshire people that one of the most odious MP's in the UK keeps getting voted in.

Eleanor Burns · 13 days ago · Report

A member of parliament posts his opinions in a public forum, finds few people agree with him, so deduces that he must be the victim of an evil conspiracy? To coin a phrase, diddums ... Perhaps he should try a more private profession.

Jennifer Charles · 13 days ago · Report

As a trans woman, I was upset at being bullied and discriminated against by Mr Davies. I posted comments in the Argus to defend myself and clarify points of law. I am not mentally ill or "confused" and there is no danger to other women when I use the loo. I am not part of a "pro-trans group" organising politically against Mr Davies. Trans people are very few in number yet are being demonised and isolated by people wishing to score political points. It's making going out in public unsafe for me.

Julie Carpenter · 13 days ago · Report

As a woman I couldn't care less if a transgender person uses the same loo; changing room etc. I certainly wouldn't know whether they had 'male genitalia' as I can't see through cubicle walls and, as a well brought up person I don't stare at strangers in a state of undress! In any case I am closer to these apparently hazardous appendages in a crowded lift or train - so this all seems like nonsense to me.

Add Your Comment

You don't need an account to leave a comment

By posting your comment you agree to our T & C